Third-year quarterback Joe Milton made his first-ever NFL start for the Eagles last Sunday in a 19-11 loss to the Giants in Philadelphia.
The team has its bye this weekend so it is not clear when—or if—Milton will have another starting opportunity.
NFL quarterback alum Matt Mauck can relate to the uncertainty around Milton’s next starting role. Mauck, a seventh-round pick of the Broncos in 2004, did not play in Denver that season but did sign as a free agent with the Titans the following year.
Mauck started one game that 2005 season in Tennessee. Not only was it the last game of the season but it was Mauck’s last—and only—start of his NFL career. He was waived in training camp the following summer and decided to move on to the stage in his life.
He recently spoke to The Athletic about that one career start 21 years ago.
“That first start against the Jaguars was a big opportunity and a big game for me,” Mauck recalls. “My hotel room in Jacksonville the night before the game butted up next to a couple of my teammates. I heard some of the guys up until two or three in the morning having a good time. We already were out of the playoffs, so I thought to myself: ‘I think I am the only one who actually wants to win this game’. We knew we were going to get a high draft pick whether we won or lost. It added a little extra pressure. Not that I couldn’t rely on my teammates, but I felt I was going to have to do this myself a little bit.”
The Titans lost that finale and selected Vince Young of Texas the following spring as the first overall pick of the 2006 Draft. They also added Kerry Collins as a veteran QB backup. Mauck was expendable.
“That one start was a little bit of a blur,” the 47-year-old Mauck says now. “I left disappointed that it didn’t go as well as I had planned. It was a missed opportunity. If I played well in that game, my career could have been a bit different.”
Like Mauck, many of us believe that our best game was the one we never got to play. However, Mauck’s post-NFL life has turned out well since being cut by the Titans. He enrolled and graduated from the University of Colorado School of Dental Medicine and has been treating patients in Aurora (CO) since 2010. He also has stayed close to the game since his dental practice—Mauck & Ricci—serves as the official dentist of the Broncos, the team that originally drafted him.
We at NFL Alumni wish our brother Matt Mauck continued success. We also look forward to Joe Milton getting a second quarterback start with the Eagles or wherever his NFL career takes him.